Posted in

How does Aluminum – plastic Laminated Film compare to metal packaging?

Hey everyone, it’s Jamie here – I’ve been with an aluminum-plastic laminated film supply company for almost 8 years now, and let me tell you, one question comes up more than any other from potential clients: “How’s your stuff stack up against metal packaging?” Aluminum-plastic Laminated Film

Most people think metal packaging is the go-to for durable, safe, long-lasting products – and yeah, it’s got its place. But over the years, I’ve watched more and more brands switch to our aluminum-plastic laminated films, and not just because we make a good product. There are real, tangible differences that make sense for everything from food and pharmaceuticals to electronics and everyday consumer goods. Today, I’m breaking this down straight – no fancy jargon, no sales fluff, just what I’ve seen on the ground.

First, let’s start with the basics so we’re all on the same page. Metal packaging is mostly stuff like aluminum cans, steel drums, tin containers – rigid, solid, single-material (well, mostly, but the core is metal). Our aluminum-plastic laminated films? They’re flexible pouches, wrappers, or liners made by bonding aluminum foil to plastic layers (think polyethylene, polyester, nylon) – basically a thin, stretchy composite. The first big thing that hits clients is weight, and that’s where we’ve got a clear win.

Last year, I worked with a specialty snack brand that was using steel cans for their trail mix. Each can weighed 12 ounces, and shipping 10,000 units from their factory to west coast warehouses was costing them $1,200 in freight. When they switched to our aluminum-plastic stand-up pouches, each unit weighed just 2 ounces – that cut their freight cost to $200 for the same 10k units. That’s a 83% savings right there, and it’s not just shipping. Retailers pay attention to shelf weight too – lighter packaging means easier stocking, especially for smaller stores that don’t have heavy lift equipment. Metal’s rigid, so even when it’s empty, it takes up way more space in storage and transit. Our films are rollable, so you can stock 10x more material in the same warehouse space, and finished pouches flatten out when empty, cutting reverse logistics waste too.

But wait, some folks will say “metal’s way more durable – it won’t puncture.” Let’s be real here: for most products, puncture resistance isn’t the big risk it used to be. Yeah, a steel can won’t get a hole from a rough warehouse drop, but our aluminum-plastic films can be formulated to hit similar specs. For example, we use a nylon inner layer that’s thick enough to resist most sharp edges from product contents – I’ve seen our pouches hold up to diced pineapple with sharp bits, no leaks. Where metal actually has an edge is for heavy, sharp industrial goods, like machine parts or large chemical drums. But for 90% of consumer and food products? The puncture risk is minimal, and we make sure our films meet industry safety standards to handle that.

Next up, barrier properties – this is huge, especially for food and pharma. Metal packaging is great at blocking light, oxygen, and moisture – it’s why your soda in a can stays carbonated for years. But aluminum-plastic films? We can customize the barrier way more than metal. Let’s say you have a protein powder that goes rancid if it hits even a tiny bit of oxygen – we can add a high-barrier EVOH (ethylene vinyl alcohol) layer to our laminate that blocks 99.9% of oxygen, same as a metal can. But if you have a bag of potato chips that only needs to stay fresh for 3 months? We can skip the extra barrier layer, cut material cost by 20%, and make the pouch way lighter. That customization is a game-changer – metal’s a one-size-fits-all (or close to it) when it comes to barrier, but our films are tailored to your exact shelf life needs.

I learned this the hard way a couple years back when a craft brewery client came to us. They were using metal cans for their beer, but customers were complaining about “metallic aftertaste.” Turns out, the metal lining (even the food-grade kind) was leaching a tiny bit of chemical into the beer over time – not enough to be unsafe, but enough to ruin the taste. Our aluminum-plastic films have a polypropylene inner layer that’s completely inert, so no aftertaste, no leaching. The client switched, and their repeat orders went up 15% because of the better flavor. Metal’s safe, but it’s not neutral – and for products where taste is everything, that’s a big deal.

Oh, and let’s talk about form and function. Metal packaging can only be shaped into so many forms: cylinders, squares, maybe some odd rectangles. But our films are flexible, so we can make stand-up pouches, flat pouches, squeeze tubes, even 3D shapes that conform to the product. That’s why you see snack brands using our pouches with resealable zippers – metal cans don’t have that easy, cheap reseal option. A client who makes organic cat food told me their customers hated having to transfer leftover food from a metal can to a container because the can was hard to open and leftover food went bad fast. Our pouches have a heat-sealed zipper that keeps the food fresh for 2 weeks after opening, and the pouch’s shape lets you squeeze out every last bit of food, no waste.

What about sustainability? This is probably the biggest topic right now, and I’m not going to lie – metal has a rep for being recyclable, which is true. But most metal packaging (like food cans) gets recycled, but only about 50% of them actually do get sent to recycling centers, and the ones that do require a ton of energy to melt down – like 95% less energy than making new metal, but the collection rate is low. Our aluminum-plastic laminated films – wait, they’re multi-material, so they’re a bit trickier to recycle, but that’s changing fast. We work with recycling partners now that can process our laminates into plastic lumber, garden edging, even new packaging material. Plus, because our films use 70% less material by weight than metal packaging, the carbon footprint to make each unit is way lower. For every 10,000 pouches we make, the carbon emissions are 1,200 lbs, compared to 8,500 lbs for the same number of metal cans. That’s a huge win for brands trying to hit their carbon neutrality goals.

Wait, let’s not skip the downsides for us, because I’m being honest. Metal packaging is way easier to recycle right now for most consumers – you just toss a can in the bin, no sorting. Our laminates still require special recycling, though more curbside programs are starting to accept them. Also, for very high-heat applications, metal’s better – if you’re packaging something that needs to go through a retort sterilizer (high-pressure, high-heat to kill bacteria), metal cans hold up perfectly, but our films can too, as long as we use the right plastic layers (like polyester that’s heat-resistant). We’ve had clients test our retortable pouches for canned tuna, and they work just as well as metal, but the brand saved 25% on production costs.

Another thing: cost. When brands first ask for quotes, they usually think metal is cheaper, but that’s only for large bulk orders. For small to mid-sized runs, our aluminum-plastic films come out to 10-15% less per unit. The setup cost for metal molds is insane – you have to pay thousands of dollars to make a custom can mold, whereas with our films, the die cutting setup is a few hundred bucks. That’s why startups love working with us – they can test a product without dropping $10k on a mold for metal packaging.

I’ve had so many clients come in with “I’ve always used metal, I don’t want to switch” – and most of the time, after we walk through their specific needs, they end up switching, or at least splitting their packaging between metal and our films. For example, a pet food brand we work with uses metal drums for bulk ingredients, but our pouches for retail-ready bags – the retail sales went up because the pouches look nicer on shelves, are lighter to carry, and keep the food fresher.

Here’s the thing I tell everyone: there’s no “best” – it’s about what works for your product, your customers, and your bottom line. If you’re packaging heavy industrial chemicals that need to last 10 years, metal’s the way to go. If you’re packaging cookies, protein bars, or skincare products that need to stay fresh, taste good, and be easy to ship and sell? Our aluminum-plastic laminated films are usually the better pick.

I don’t do sales pitches, but if you’re curious about testing, or you’re tired of overpaying for metal packaging, hit me up. We can send you a sample pouch, run a quick cost comparison for your order, and answer any questions you have – no strings attached.

Food Packaging Film Series References:

  1. Food and Drug Administration. (2022). Food Contact Materials: Aluminum Laminated Films. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
  2. Sustainable Packaging Coalition. (2023). Multi-Material Packaging: Environmental Performance Metrics.
  3. Packaging World. (2024). Flexible Packaging vs Rigid: Trends in Consumer Goods.
  4. International Organization for Standardization. (2022). Barrier Properties of Packaging Materials. ISO 11455:2022.

Qingzhou Bright Packaging Technology Co., Ltd.
As one of the leading aluminum-plastic laminated film manufacturers and suppliers in China, we also support customized service. Welcome to wholesale high quality aluminum-plastic laminated film at competitive price from our factory. If you have any enquiry about quotation, please feel free to email us.
Address: 1 Yanying Road, Naoshan Development Zone, Qingzhou, Shandong Province, China
E-mail: Sales12@brpack.com
WebSite: https://www.qzbrpack.com/